Read more
Everyday language is saturated with appeals to what might be the case or to what
must be true or to what
cannot happen. Possibility, necessity, and impossibility are
modal terms, and philosophers have long wondered how to best understand them. This volume traces the history of some of the most prominent and important contributions to our understanding of possibility and necessity and related concepts over the past two and half millennia of western philosophy, from ancient Greek philosophers through current debates in the 21st century.
List of contents
- Acknowledgements
- Contributors
- Series Editor's Foreword
- Introduction
- YITZHAK Y. MELAMED and SAMUEL NEWLANDS
- 1 Aristotle on Modality
- MARKO MALINK
- 2 Modality in Medieval Latin Philosophy
- SIMO KNUUTTILA
- Reflection: Necessity in the Cosmology of Tommaso Campanella
- EMANUELE COSTA
- 3 Modality and Essence in Early Modern Philosophy: Descartes, Malebranche, and Locke
- ANAT SCHECHTMAN
- 4 Crescas and Spinoza on Modality
- YITZHAK Y. MELAMED
- 5 Leibniz on Modality
- SAMUEL NEWLANDS
- Reflection: The Infinity of Worlds in Modern Kabbalah.
- JONATHAN GARB
- 6 Hume on Modal Discourse
- THOMAS HOLDEN
- 7 Modality in Kant and Hegel
- NICHOLAS STANG
- Reflection: Music and Modality
- DOMENIICA G. ROMAGNI
- 8 Modality in 20th Century Philosophy
- KRIS McDANIEL
- Reflection: Vacuism and the Strangeness of Impossibility.
- ROHAN FRENCH
- 9 Modality and Essence in Contemporary Metaphysics
- KATHRIN KOSLICKI
- Reflection: Clarice Lispector - Writing of Necessity
- PAULA MARCHESINI
About the author
Yitzhak Y. Melamed is the Charlotte Bloomberg Professor of Philosophy at Johns Hopkins University. He is the author of Spinoza's Metaphysics: Substance and Thought (Oxford 2013), and Spinoza's Labyrinths (Oxford, forthcoming). His research has been featured in the BBC (The World Tonight), LeMond, Ha'aretz, and Kan Tarbut (Israeli Cultural Radio).
Samuel Newlands is the Carl E Koch Professor of Philosophy and the chair of the Philosophy Department at the University of Notre Dame. He has published dozens of articles on early modern philosophy and has directed large research projects on hope and optimism and the problem of evil. He has also received two NEH fellowships, including to support work on his monograph Reconceiving Spinoza (OUP, 2018) and two new book projects in early modern studies.
Summary
Modality: A History provides readers a sweeping study of the history of philosophical work on modal concepts. Everyday discourse is saturated with appeals to what might be the case or to what must be true or to what cannot happen. Possibility, necessity, and impossibility are modal terms, and philosophers have long wondered how to best understand them. This volume traces the history of some of the most prominent and important contributions to our understanding of possibility and necessity over the past two and half millennia of western philosophy, from ancient Greek philosophers through current debates in the 21st century.
Over the course of nine chapters from prominent scholars, this volume traces a history of modal theorizing that begins with extended discussions of Aristotle and the Stoics. Several chapters discuss insights and disagreements among Latin, Arabic, and Jewish medieval scholastics, such as Al-Ghazâlî, Scotus, and Crescas. Three chapters center on early modern philosophers, whose modal views were deeply shaped by this conceptual inheritance but also departed from it in significant ways: Descartes, Malebranche, Locke, Spinoza, Leibniz, and Hume. Kant and Hegel's modal contributions are presented in their own chapter, and another chapter traces the legacy of Kant's account on early-to-mid 20th century modal views, including Husserl, Heidegger, Russell, and Quine.
The revival of modal metaphysics in the more recent work of Kripke, Marcus, and Lewis has led to a new flourishing of modal theories, including in recent debates among neo-Aristotelians, as the final chapter illustrates. Although modal concepts are interesting and important on their own, theories of modality often intersect with other significant philosophical topics, such as time, freedom, and God. Modal concepts also extend beyond metaphysics. To illustrate the role of modality in other domains, several small-scale studies, or Reflections, are dispersed among these main chapters on modality in cosmology, religion, music, literature, and logic. Readers will learn how a seemingly timeless and changeless cluster of modal concepts have undergone significant revisions and enjoy a rich developmental history.
