Grave Matters - The Controversy over Excavating California's Buried Indigenous Past

"The history of the treatment of Native remains in California and the story of the complicated relationship between researcher and researched"--

About the author

Tony Platt is the author of more than ten books and 150 essays and articles on race, inequality, and social justice in American history, among them Beyond These Walls: Rethinking Crime and Punishment in the United States, Bloodlines: Recovering Hitler's Nuremberg Laws, From Patton's Trophy to Public Memorial, and The Child Savers: The Invention of Delinquency. Platt, now a professor emeritus, taught at the University of Chicago, the University of California, Berkeley, and California State University, Sacramento, where he received awards for teaching and scholarship. Platt has written for the Los Angeles Times, the San Francisco Chronicle, Truthdig, History News Network, Z Magazine, Monthly Review, and the Guardian, and his commentaries have aired on NPR. His publications have been translated into four languages. Platt lives in Berkeley and Big Lagoon, California.

Summary

How do we reconcile the sanctity of Indigenous burial grounds with the desire to study them?

Whether by curious Boy Scouts and “backyard archaeologists” or competitive collectors and knowledge-hungry anthropologists, the excavation of Native remains is a practice fraught with injustice and simmering resentments.

Grave Matters is the history of the treatment of Native remains in California and the story of the complicated relationship between researcher and researched. Tony Platt begins his journey with his son’s funeral at Big Lagoon, a seaside village in pastoral Humboldt County in Northern California, once O-pyúweg, a bustling center for the Yurok and the site of a plundered native cemetery. Platt travels the globe in search of the answer to the question: How do we reconcile a place of extraordinary beauty with its horrific past?

Grave Matters centers the Yurok people and the eventual movement to repatriate remains and reclaim ancient rights, but it is also a universal story of coming to terms with the painful legacy of a sorrowful past. This book, originally published in 2011, is updated here with a preface by the author.

Additional text

“Tony Platt’s book delves so deeply into the history of genocide, racism, and systems of oppression that serve as the foundation of the United States of America. We can all learn from his elaborate historical research on the Indigenous history of what is now known as California. Grave Matters is no less relevant now than when it was originally published. It should be required reading for everyone seeking out truth in 2021 and beyond.” — Nazune Menka, M. S., J. D. (Athabascan & Lumbee), Tribal Cultural Resources Policy Fellow, Berkeley Law

“A new edition on the tenth anniversary of Tony Platt's extraordinary work, Grave Matters, could not come at a more important moment when the precariousness of the planet itself recalls the genocide unleashed by European and Euroamerican colonialism that endures and continues to haunt descendants of the perpetrators, many of whom engage in ghoulish thefts of the remains of the dead. In his own grieving for a lost son, Platt enters a circle of grieving in the Yurok nation, becoming a powerful voice for decolonization and the protection of Indigenous grave sites.” —Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz, author of An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States

“This meticulously researched, nuanced, and powerful narrative weaves together social, cultural, and personal histories as it confronts the plundering of California Indian graves and recounts the persistence and indelible resistance of Tribes to the taking of their ancestors and belongings. This is a profound—and profoundly unsettling—work of critical history.” —Seth Davis, Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley School of Law

“We have taught Grave Matters and it always worked tragically well. It has significantly influenced our thinking about California history.” —Damon Akins and William Bauer, authors of We Are The Land: A History of Native California 

 “An exemplary work of engaged scholarship that combines a carefully researched and beautifully written local history of a fascinating region with principled ruminations and reflections about our pressing contemporary civic and scholarly responsibilities. This is how social and cultural history should be written.” —George Lipsitz, professor of Black Studies, University of California, Santa Barbara; author of How Racism Takes Place

“A shocking expose filled with entirely new material, and yet also much more: an indictment of some of 20th century anthropology's most famous names; an account of tribal struggles for control over their dead; and a meditation about history, violence, and the tension between memory and forgetting. Tony Platt has given us an original, haunting, and necessary tour de force of a book.” —Orin Starn, professor of Cultural Anthropology and History, Duke University; author of Ishi’s Brain: In Search of America’s Last “Wild” Indian

“A truly marvelous account. The conqueror usually writes history. Now, thanks to Tony Platt digging up the facts, everybody knows the truth.” —Joy Sundberg, Cher-Ae Heights Indian Community of the Trinidad Rancheria



“A fine mix of the personal, the historic, the dispassionate, and the fierce. It’s always good to have one’s moral outrage rekindled when the coals burn low in daily life.” —Dick Walker, professor emeritus of Geography, UC Berkeley, and author of Pictures of a Gone City: Tech and the Dark Side of Prosperity in the San Francisco Bay Area

Product details

• Authors: Tony Platt, Platt Tony
• Publisher: Heyday books
• Languages: English
• Product format: Paperback / Softback
• Released: 16.11.2021
• EAN: 9781597145596
• ISBN: 978-1-59714-559-6
• No. of pages: 256
• Subjects: Humanities, art, music > History > Pre and early history; Non-fiction book > History > Miscellaneous; Ethnic Studies, SOCIAL SCIENCE / Archaeology, Indigenous Peoples, Relating to indigenous peoples, History of the Americas, SOCIAL SCIENCE / Native American Studies